Fasting Without Breaking: The Ruling on Sawm al-Wisal
In the journey of spiritual devotion, some may feel inclined to push their limits by fasting consecutively without eating at night. This practice is known in Islamic jurisprudence as Sawm al-Wisal. But is it permissible according to the Sunnah?
Let’s explore the textual evidence and the differing opinions of the great Imams.
1. The Scriptural Basis: "Complete the Fast Until Night"
The Qur'an provides a clear boundary for the duration of a fast:
"...Then complete the fast until the night." (QS. Al-Baqarah: 187).
This verse indicates that the night serves as the ghaayah (the final limit). To extend the fast into the night as a ritual act contradicts the literal command of Allah. This is further reinforced by a stern warning from the Prophet Muhammad (ﷺ):
"Beware of Al-Wisal! Beware of Al-Wisal!" (Narrated by Al-Bukhari).
2. Scholarly Opinions: Makruh or Haraam?
The majority of scholars (Jumhur) consider Wisal to be Makruh (disliked). However, some scholars deem it Haraam (prohibited) because it opposes the outward meaning of the Qur'an and resembles the practices of the Ahl al-Kitab (People of the Book), whom we are encouraged to distinguish ourselves from.
The Prophet (ﷺ) said:
"The difference between our fasting and the fasting of the People of the Book is the eating of Suhoor (the pre-dawn meal)." (Narrated by Muslim and Abu Dawud).
3. The Prophet’s Unique Status
A famous dialogue occurred when the Sahabah noticed the Prophet (ﷺ) himself sometimes practiced Wisal. Abu Sa’id al-Khudri (RA) narrated that the Prophet (ﷺ) said:
"Do not practice Wisal. Whoever among you insists on it, let him only extend it until the time of Suhoor." The companions asked, "But you practice Wisal, O Messenger of Allah?" He replied, "I am not like you; my Lord provides me with food and drink (spiritually)." (Sahih Bukhari).
The Takeaway: For the average believer, the absolute limit for delaying Iftar (breaking the fast) is the time of Suhoor. Extending it into the next day without eating is prohibited according to Imams Ahmad, Ishaq, and Ibnu Wahb.
4. When Does the Fast End?
The Prophet (ﷺ) defined the exact moment of Iftar as follows:
"When the night approaches from here (the east) and the day retreats from there (the west), then the fasting person should break their fast." (Narrated by Bukhari and Muslim).
5. Starting a Sunnah Fast: Must You Finish It?
A fascinating debate exists regarding Tathawwu' (voluntary/sunnah) fasts. If you start a voluntary fast and then decide to break it, do you have to make it up (Qadha)?
The Hanafi View: Mandatory Completion
Based on the verse "Then complete the fast until the night," the Hanafi school argues that once you begin any fast, it becomes a duty to complete it. Breaking it requires a makeup day. They rely on the legal maxim al-amru lil-wujuub (a command implies an obligation) and the verse:
"And do not let your deeds go to waste." (QS. Muhammad: 33).
The Maliki View: It Depends
Imam Malik distinguishes between the cause of the break. If you intentionally cancel the act, you must perform Qadha. However, if an external factor or valid excuse forced you to break it, no makeup is required.
The Shafi’i & Hanbali View: The "Commander" of Oneself
These schools are more lenient, citing the verse:
"...There is no ground for complaint against those who do good..." (QS. At-Tawbah: 91).
They also rely on the Hadith:
"The one performing a voluntary fast is the commander of himself." (If they wish, they fast; if they wish, they break it). No Qadha is required, except for the Hajj in the Hanbali school.
Summary Table: Rulings on Voluntary Fasts
| School of Thought | Must Complete? | Must Make Up (Qadha)? |
| Hanafi | Yes | Always |
| Maliki | Yes | If broken intentionally |
| Shafi'i | No | Recommended, not mandatory |
| Hanbali | No | No (except for Hajj) |
Posting Komentar untuk "Fasting Without Breaking: The Ruling on Sawm al-Wisal"